logo EHM

Marketing Psychology: 5 Little Known Facts About Consumer Behavior in Advertising

picture of Richard Shotton

Richard Shotton

Author, The Choice Factory

What is marketing psychology?

When it comes to digital marketing it’s easy to drown ourselves in endless data analytics, campaign results, and market research. But marketing boils down to one thing only–humans. Marketing psychology is the study of consumer psychology and the reasoning behind why we make decisions.

Who is Richard Shotton?

My guest today is Richard Shotton, the author of The Choice Factory: 25 Behavioral Biases That Influence What We Buy. He’s also the head of behavioral science for Manning Gottlieb OMD, the #1 advertising agency in Europe.

5 Little-Known Facts About Consumer Behavior

  1. Pratfall Effect: If you can admit a weakness or flaw, you become more appealing to your audience.
  2. Confirmation Bias: We’re very good at maintaining our existing point of view.
  3. Our Habits: You can persuade people in the moments when their habits become destabilized.
  4. Brand Purpose: Not every company needs to have have a higher purpose beyond profit.
  5. Personalization: Don’t apply it to such a degree that you lose the essence of your brand.

The Pratfall Effect

The pratfall effect is a counter-intuitive idea that was first discussed by Eliott Aronson, a professor of psychology at Harvard in the 1960s. According to this theory, you become more appealing after you admit a weakness or you exhibit a flaw.

In marketing, this applies because one of the biggest issues we face is that people don’t trust brands. Once you’ve admitted a flaw, you’re demonstrating your honesty and the rest of your claims suddenly become more believable.

Confirmation Bias

Our brain instinctively resist new information due to confirmation bias. As Richard Shotton explains, if you already dislike a brand, your brain will continue to come up with counter arguments to maintain its existing point of view.

You can counteract this in marketing by reaching your audience at moments of distraction, because they’re potentially persuadable at this point. And you can do this by thinking about the body language and the tone of your advertising.

Our Habits

What are the moments when people’s habits become destabilized? According to consumer psychology, we can encourage people to buy our products during major life events. Richard Shotton conducted research where he discovered that people are 2-3 times more likely to try a new brand after undergoing a life event.

These life events can include getting married, divorced, retiring, moving, having your first child, or starting a new job. These are when our habits are in flux and we’re open to buying new products to fit these changes.

Brand Purpose

There’s a current trend in marketing at the moment where companies are trying to find a single way of answering briefs. This can go wrong in a lot ways. Because the problems that your target market will face are varied — and one solution is impossible.

Richard explains brand purpose as an example. In some circumstances, brands should have a higher order beyond profit but it can also lead to the wrong approach if you try to apply purpose to everything. Remember the infamous Pepsi protest campaign? That’s proof on how this tactic can fail.


If you take personalization in marketing too far, there can be huge implications. In this interview, Richard shares a theory from Kevin Simler that explains the value of a brand is in it’s shared cultural meaning.

If you’re targeting your audience with different messages it can be great in the beginning. However, eventually people will overhear those messages and understand that your brand actually stands for nothing.

listen to this episode

We covered:

Full Transcript:

Louis: Bonjour, bonjour! Welcome to another episode of EveryoneHatesMarketers.com — the marketing podcast for marketers, founders, and tech people all who are just sick of shady aggressive marketing. I’m your host, Louis Grenier.In today’s episode, you will learn how findings from psychology can be applied to advertising and how you can become a better marketer thanks to those findings. My guest today is the author of a really good book The Choice Factory: 25 Behavioral Biases That Influence What We Buy. He’s the head of behavioral science for MG OMD (Manning Gottlieb OMD). Which I’m gonna admit, I didn’t know about until I read more about you.

But apparently it’s #1 advertising agency in Europe, so it’s kind of a big deal. But he’s doing it part-time because the rest of the time he’s freelancing — meaning he can say a lot of swear words during the podcast.

I’m super happy to have you on board, Richard Shotton. Let’s hear what you’ve got.

Richard: Very nice to meet you. Looking forward to chatting.

Louis: Let me tell you a little story. When I was 18 or 19, I went to visit my brother in Paris. My brother being older than I am, he was reading a lot of books and one of those books was a French book. I’m gonna say it in French and then I’ll try to translate. Which was called Le petit traité de manipulation à l’usage

Next: check out the 500+ marketing resources mentioned on the podcast over the years (sorted by the number of mentions and format).

Become a confident marketer that gets real results (without treating people like garbage)

Bonjour bonjour! I’m Louis Grenier I’m a no-fluff marketer living in Dublin, Ireland (but yeah, I’m French).

Sign up to receive my no-fluff, 7-lesson email course based on what I’ve learned over the last 10 years as a marketer (+ more than 150 hours of interviews with no-bullshit marketers like Seth Godin, Mark Ritson, or Joanna Wiebe).

I believe you can treat people the way you’d like to be treated and still generate results without using sleazy, aggressive, hack-y marketing. This is why I’ve started Everyone Hates Marketers – a no-fluff, actionable marketing podcast – as a side project in 2017.

Since then, EHM has been downloaded more than 500,000 times and got praises from many from industry leaders as a marketing podcast you can learn stuff from (crazy, right?!).

7-lesson email course to become a confident & effective marketer

Related Content


How to Improve Your Marketing With Social Proof (4-Step Framework)

picture of Louis Nicholls

Louis Nicholls


What Motivates Human Behavior: 5 Drivers You Should Know About

picture of Susan Weinschenk

Susan Weinschenk

© 2017 - 2020